Projects as Production Systems: A Lean Approach to Construction Success
In the construction industry, projects are traditionally viewed as one-off efforts, with distinct timelines, budgets, and deliverables. However, adopting a "projects as production systems" perspective has proven transformative for firms striving to enhance productivity, reliability, and value. Rooted in Lean Construction principles, this approach views each project as a series of interrelated processes aimed at delivering predictable and continuous flows of value.
This shift in mindset requires embracing tools and systems like the Last Planner System® (LPS) and recognizing the holistic interdependence of processes, people, and resources. By exploring the key components of projects as production systems, we can uncover strategies that not only boost efficiency but also position companies as leaders in the ever-competitive construction landscape.
What Are Projects as Production Systems?
At its core, the idea of treating construction projects as production systems challenges the notion of projects as discrete, siloed events. Instead, projects are understood as complex, interconnected systems comprising workflows, handoffs, and cycles that need to be meticulously planned, executed, and continuously improved.
In this system-oriented view, every activity, whether design, procurement, or installation, serves as a production task contributing to the final product. Managing these tasks involves optimizing not just individual activities but the relationships between them.
Lean Construction, a philosophy adapted from Lean Manufacturing, provides the tools and principles necessary to manage these production systems effectively. These include:
Eliminating Waste: Reducing activities that do not add value, such as waiting times or rework.
Enhancing Flow: Creating smooth transitions between project phases to maintain continuity.
Maximizing Value: Focusing on delivering what the customer truly needs.
Key Lean Components in Construction Projects
1. Lean Principles in Construction
Lean principles offer the foundation for managing construction projects as production systems. Applying these principles involves a cultural shift across project teams, stakeholders, and contractors.
Respect for People: Collaboration is critical. In Lean Construction, respect means engaging the workforce in decision-making, fostering trust, and promoting transparency.
Continuous Improvement (Kaizen): Projects benefit from an iterative process of learning and refining workflows. Daily and weekly reviews ensure problems are addressed promptly.
Pull Planning: Work is driven by downstream needs rather than upstream scheduling, ensuring that processes are aligned with actual demand.
By adhering to these principles, teams can break free from reactive project management and adopt a proactive stance, reducing risks and delays.
2. The Last Planner System®: Turning Plans Into Reliable Actions
One of the most effective tools in implementing a production system approach is the Last Planner System®. Developed by Glenn Ballard and Greg Howell, LPS aims to improve workflow reliability and enhance collaboration among all project participants.
Core Elements of LPS:
Master Planning: Long-term, high-level plans that set project milestones and overarching goals.
Phase Planning: Collaborative planning sessions where key milestones are broken down into phases.
Lookahead Planning: A six- to eight-week window where constraints are identified and resolved.
Weekly Work Planning: Detailed short-term plans that define what will be done each week.
Plan Percent Complete (PPC): A metric used to track the reliability of commitments and improve planning accuracy over time.
The success of LPS lies in its ability to bridge the gap between high-level planning and on-the-ground execution. It ensures that commitments made by the team are realistic, actionable, and aligned with the broader production system.
3. Collaboration and Communication
Effective collaboration is a cornerstone of Lean Construction. Traditional project management often fosters silos, leading to miscommunication and inefficiencies. In contrast, the production system approach emphasizes:
Co-creation of Plans: Involving all stakeholders, from designers to subcontractors, in the planning process ensures alignment and buy-in.
Real-time Communication: Utilizing digital tools like Building Information Modeling (BIM) enhances visibility and transparency, reducing misunderstandings.
Integrated Project Delivery (IPD): Aligning the interests of all parties through shared risk and reward structures.
Collaboration isn't just about tools—it's about culture. Projects thrive when teams embrace shared accountability and trust.
4. Metrics and Feedback Loops
In a production system, metrics are not just performance indicators; they are tools for learning and improvement. Lean Construction advocates for tracking key performance metrics such as:
Cycle Times: Measuring the duration of specific processes to identify bottlenecks.
Work in Progress (WIP): Balancing workload to prevent overburdening teams.
Reliability Metrics: Using PPC to evaluate the consistency of planned versus completed tasks.
Feedback loops, such as daily huddles and after-action reviews, help teams identify lessons learned and apply them to future workflows.
The Benefits of Viewing Projects as Production Systems
Adopting this approach yields tangible and intangible benefits:
1. Improved Predictability
By focusing on reliable workflows and reducing variability, construction teams can better anticipate project outcomes. This predictability builds trust with clients and reduces costly surprises.
2. Enhanced Productivity
Streamlined processes eliminate waste, minimize delays, and ensure resources are utilized effectively. Teams spend less time waiting and more time creating value.
3. Higher Quality
A production system prioritizes continuous improvement, leading to fewer defects and higher-quality deliverables.
4. Happier Stakeholders
When projects run smoothly, stakeholders—clients, contractors, and team members—enjoy greater satisfaction and reduced stress.
Challenges and Solutions
While the benefits are clear, implementing projects as production systems is not without challenges.
Cultural Resistance: Teams accustomed to traditional methods may resist change.
Solution: Provide training and emphasize the long-term benefits of Lean practices.
Lack of Coordination: Misalignment between stakeholders can derail production systems.
Solution: Use tools like BIM and IPD to foster collaboration and transparency.
Fragmented Supply Chains: Construction often involves multiple subcontractors with varying priorities.
Solution: Apply Lean principles across the supply chain to align goals and ensure consistency.
Becoming an Industry Leader
Embracing the "projects as production systems" mindset is more than a technical shift—it’s a leadership opportunity. By championing Lean Construction and tools like the Last Planner System®, companies can position themselves as forward-thinking authorities in the industry.
To achieve this, industry leaders must:
Invest in continuous learning and improvement.
Advocate for collaborative practices across projects.
Share success stories to inspire others and build credibility.
Conclusion
Track work across the enterprise through an open, collaborative platform. Link issues across Jira and ingest data from other software development tools, so your IT support and operations teams have richer contextual information to rapidly respond to requests, incidents, and changes.